My trusty old ice cream maker, if she could talk, would beseech in her shrill voice: “please don’t give up on me yet!” And I won’t, because even though a bone-chilling drizzle fell outside earlier this week, and a big batch of chicken stock bubbled away on the stove, I’m not ready to throw in the towel. I would miss whisking together a batch of ice cream too much and will likely be going strong into the winter. Ice cream maker: if you thought you would ever get to hibernate, think again.
But my focus is changing a bit. Where I craved bright, juicy fruit flavors when the weather was hot–things like strawberry and peach and very lemony lemon to set off the fresh blueberries we picked–I’m going for spicy and deep now. Lavender-honey is still in the game, because it tastes dreamy with roasted pears. I just plucked the seeds from our runaway fennel plants and must try this recipe from Orangette. But before I do that, I can’t wait to reprise what turned out to be the home run of the summer–and to share it with you.
My sister, who is prone to kitchen epiphanies, came up with the idea for this one. If I can say one thing about Cass, it’s that she's the flavor genius of the family–no exaggeration. She’s never had a speck of training, and I’m not sure she actually owns a single cookbook–but she somehow senses in her gut what will work and, most of the time, it does. Chocolate with a little salt? She was onto that long before it became trendy. Grilled pizza with duck confit, pickled onions, jalapenos, and goat cheese? Why not? Drizzled with her cilantro-based green sauce? Insanely good–though the first time she told me of this creation I couldn’t wrap my head around it, because my imagination just does not know the bounds hers does.
Since she doesn't really follow recipes, sometimes she’ll get an idea and call me up to see how, from a technical standpoint, she might work it into service. It always perplexes me to see an urgent text from her asking me at what temperature she should, say, roast a chicken–because I think of her as a pro. This July, when she and her family planned on joining us for a weekend in Connecticut, and she said “How about chocolate cardamom ice cream? Can you figure it out?” I knew we had a winner, and I knew that by pooling our resources we could make it happen. And we did! The recipe below was born while the cicadas buzzed outside, and the grass felt warm under our feet…but I know it will taste just as good with snow drifting against the windows.
We both have a thing for cardamom, with its heady twang–which, as it turns out, sings along nicely with the rich chocolate (and if we have another thing in common it's our fetish for obscene concentrations of chocolate…I'm talking migraine-inducing). If cardamom happens to be your cilantro, though, you can skip it and just make an ultra-chocolate ice cream with this recipe.A word about the technique here: I roast and caramelize the crushed cardamom pods for a bit before mixing them with the other ingredients–it's a technique borrowed from Daniel Boulud, from The Café Boulud Cookbook (his recipe is for coffee-cardamom pots de creme). Don't be scared if you've never made caramel before, as the idea here is not to make a perfect, smooth caramel but to deepen and bring out the cardamom flavors more.
Also, for ice cream, I generally make the French-style custard variety–which calls for egg yolks. In order to make this type of ice cream you have to literally cook it, gently tempering the hot milk and cream mixture into the egg yolks so they won't scramble and give you gross, lumpy ice cream. Just be patient and, if in doubt, lower the heat.
Dark chocolate-cardamom ice cream
- 2 heaping Tablespoons cardamom pods (whole)
- 1/3 cup plus 2 Tablespoons sugar (I use natural evaporated cane juice)
- 1 1/2 cups whole milk
- 1 1/2 cups heavy cream
- 1 pinch sea salt
- 5 egg yolks
- 8 ounces bittersweet chocolate, chopped or in small chips (I use Callebaut 60%)
- Crush cardamom pods, either with a mortar and pestle, a rolling pin, or by pulsing very briefly in a food processor. The idea is not to pulverize them, but to break up the pods and release the seeds. In a heavy-bottomed pot that will be just large enough to hold the milk and cream, place the cardamom and 2 Tablespoons sugar, and heat over medium-high while stirring occasionally. Watch carefully until sugar begins to melt. Turn down the heat if caramel seems to be bubbling rapidly. As soon as sugar begins to darken a little bit, pour in milk and cream–the sugar will seize and harden, but that's OK. Heat the milk mixture slowly, stirring to loosen caramel, until liquid begins to simmer. Throw in your pinch of salt.
- Meanwhile, have the chocolate ready in a large bowl with a fine mesh strainer set over it (line with cheesecloth if need be). Whisk the remaining 1/3 cup sugar into the egg yolks. Once milk has begun to simmer, lower heat and begin whisking milk, one spoonful at a time, into yolks. Do this until about half of the milk mixture is incorporated. Next, transfer yolk mixture into the pot with the milk, and whisk to combine. Over low heat cook this mixture, not even simmering, whisking the whole time–for about 5 minutes. You want the mixture to thicken slightly and the cardamom to steep for a bit longer.
- When mixture has thickened enough to coat a spoon, carefully pour it into the strainer, over chocolate, and let that sit for a few minutes (discard solids in strainer). Then, with a clean whisk, stir until smooth. Chill the ice cream mixture in the fridge several hours, until quite cold. You can place the bowl over a larger bowl with ice in the bottom, to speed up chilling and get to your ice cream sooner. Whisk it occasionally so a skin doesn't form on top. Follow the instructions specified by the manufacturer of your ice cream maker; it generally takes about 20-25 minutes of spinning for my ice cream to thicken, plus a bit longer in the freezer to firm it up.